Tom
Reakes, Bolgers Rod, Devon North
Letter to Senator Ian Campbell,
(Federal) Minister for the Environment.
5 May 2006.
Dear Senator Campbell,
I read with great interest
your recent involvement in the Bald Hills windfarm decision. I applaud
that decision as a victory for the residents of the district, the visitors
to the area, and, of course, the parrot.
Devon North is an expansive
district situated 5-12 kms west of Yarram in southern Gippsland, Victoria.
The area around where is proposed to locate nine turbines is a mixture
of farmland, bush, and pine plantation. The turbines will be on a farmer’s
hill overlooking an exquisitely stunning creek valley. The home sites in
the immediate vicinity (within a kilometre) are largely small to medium
sized blocks.
There are a couple of operational
farms, from which is derived a living. The rest are farmlets and gardens
starting as small as ¾ acre. My own property is ¾ acre with
2 acres leased creek frontage. It is fair to say that people have come
to the area to enjoy a tree change, tranquillity, and to soak up the beauty
of the area. There are a couple of recent re-locators from the city who
have planned to build homes and retire to the loveliness that is Devon
North.
All of this is, of course,
under great threat from these proposed turbines being placed in our ‘backyards’.
For a number of us the turbines are about 500metres away. I presently have
a favourite spot in my garden in which I like to sit. As I do, I look upon
my beautiful garden, across the Stony Creek, up the hill, and can watch
the peaceful rural scene of cows on the hilltop silhouetted against the
setting sun. It is truly beautiful. This breath-taking scene is about to
be engulfed by nine huge white monsters, just 500 metres from where I sit.
However, at least, if I
manoeuvre myself I will probably be able to position one of the huge yellow
box between myself and a turbine, momentarily blocking my view. I don’t
know for how long I could maintain that position! But, for example, my
next neighbours, who are in the process of building their retirement home
will have no such choice. Looking out of their main living area, which
is comprised of floor-to-ceiling glass, they will be confronted every day
for the rest of their lives with the hideous sight of these turbines marring
their
present stunning outlook,
the reason they bought there in the first place. And that story is repeated
many times along the road.
We don’t have orange-bellied
parrots. We do have Wedge-tailed Eagles and, I’m told, Masked and Powerful
Owls. I don’t know that they will be our saviours and I’m not sure I want
them to be. This issue has to be won not only so there is a better outcome
for the environment but, as equally important, for the well-being of people:
those individuals who, right across this country, are faced with the prospect
of having to live with these things in their immediate environment, spoiling
amenity, property values, social, psychological and, even, physical well-being.
Senator, I support your
call for a national guideline/programme/understanding (whatever you call
it) for carefully planned consideration as to the placement of turbines.
I’m concerned that the Victorian Government is hell-bent on getting as
many of these things installed as possible. It makes them look good with
certain sections of the voting electorate and on the international ‘green
scene’, but it places little importance on the well-being of people in
Gippsland who are, politically speaking, of no value. Oh, I do hope that’s
not true, but this
whole issue has made me
quite cynical.
My concerns are shared,
I know, by my neighbours who are immediately affected by this proposal.
I have no hesitation in speaking on their behalf; we have become a very
close-knit community because of this. One positive, at least. Peter McGauran
has graciously agreed to look over the site and has indicated that he will
make representation to the Wellington Shire to support our case. We expect
his visit in June.
Senator Campbell, as the
Minister for Environment and Heritage, we would welcome your involvement
in this matter and ask if you might also find time to come to South Gippsland
and meet with us, have a look at the site, and listen to the concerns of
the people. I stress, we are definitely not anti-renewable energy but,
we do want to see a right and just approach in placing these turbines.
Would you please come?
Yours sincerely,
Tom Reakes.
Tom Reakes, Bolgers Road,
Devon North.
I, Tom Reakes, of 571 Bolger’s
Road, Devon North, live directly beneath the shadow of the proposed wind
turbines. I live here with my wife, Susan, daughter, Laura and grandson,
Dylan. We have been here for thirteen years. We came from suburban Melbourne
looking for a tree-change and a better quality of life. We believe we have
found it.
I am strongly and passionately
opposed to the construction of these turbines as I believe they will severely
intrude on my quality of living, (and that of my friends and neighbours)
and impose on the beauty and tranquillity of the region. I also have serious
doubts as to their efficacy in lessening the need for brown coal use in
the La Trobe Valley and therefore reducing greenhouse gas emissions. I
absolutely do not oppose the search for and implementation of alternative
energy sources. I do believe that they should not be in the ‘backyards’
of ordinary residential households. Not just mine, anybody’s. I do
not see why individuals should lose significant value of their home/investment
whilst others make a financial killing. This to me is abhorrent and immoral.
Further, I would state that
this proposal has gone all the way to seeking planning permission from
the Wellington Shire and not one representative of Synergy Wind Pty. Ltd.
has consulted with either myself or my wife. This is contrary to the press
releases/comments made by Synergy. It is fraudulent and deceptive when
that company says that they have consulted with local residents. It simply
has not happened.
There has been one point
of contact via phone, with my wife, seeking permission to place noise testing
equipment on our property. Nothing else was said on that occasion. We did
receive an introductory letter dated 7.9.2005, many months after the 50
metre testing tower was erected. It mentioned the project being in the
conceptual stage and that “this is the first in a series of letters we
will be sending to the local community..” A second letter, in response
to some questions we raised, was sent on 9.11.2005. There has been no other
contact, no more written correspondence, and certainly no consultation.
I might also add that I
sent a letter to the Attorney General, Mr Rob Hulls, looking for his help
and input on the 12.3.2005. I have heard nothing back. This present government
is not sympathetic to the concerns of ordinary residents in this issue,
particularly in a blue ribbon National seat – we have no political value
to them. They seem only concerned with quotas (1,000megawatts of alternative
energy), green votes, and, probably, carbon credits.
I would appeal to anyone
who might read this: consider the ramifications of these things, seek the
truth, know the facts. If we don’t stand up against this legalised vandalism
then these hideous monstrosities will be seen all across our beautiful
Gippsland landscape (and elsewhere). It won’t be just my backyard --- it
could be yours, too.
12 April 2006
Tom
Reakes.
12 March 2006.
Email to: 'rob.hulls@parliament.vic.gov.au'
(Mr Rob Hulls, Attorney General, Minister for Environment)
Subject: Devon North wind
turbines
My name is Tom Reakes. I
live (along with my wife, daughter and grandson) in a rather idyllic part
of Gippsland some ten kilometres west of Yarram. We enjoy rolling hills,
kookaburras, koalas, eagles….. and tranquillity. The latter is under serious
threat from the menace of nine 70 metre high wind turbines that a little-known
German company, Synergy Wind P/L, proposes to place on a hill about 500
metres behind our backdoor.
I am seriously opposed to
the placement of these ‘wind factories’ for a number of reasons. In the
first instance, and I must be frank, I do not believe that wind turbines
achieve a great deal in terms of saving green house gas emissions. I’m
sure you’ve heard the arguments and will not burden you with them here.
I only mention it because I’m not going to be dishonest and pretend that
I’m in favour of them, and if this was my only objection I would probably
remain a vocal opponent.
My greatest concern is the
social impact that these turbines are going to have directly on those people
who live within their shadow. There are a significant number of residences
within a 400 – 1000 metre radius of their proposed location. Not only will
property values be markedly affected, but the visual and aural impact of
them is simply not acceptable. I can safely say that all the residents
– none of which are anything more than hobby farmers or gardeners – came
here following a dream and looking for a tree change; a life of peace and
quiet and beauty. They all are strongly opposed to the construction of
these towers. They are simply not conducive to the ambience
of the area, or to the dreams
we all look to see become a reality. It is a cause of great frustration
and angst to myself, and other residents, that big business and government
policy can conspire to so offensively intrude into the lives of ordinary
individuals and families.
Why must these things be
placed in what is, in the main, a residential area? If they must go up,
why not in area where they do not affect or offend residents? I appeal
to you, Mr Hulls, in your official capacity, to bring pressure to bear
on those who make these life-changing, even life-shattering, decisions
to seriously reconsider their position in regard to wind turbines and their
appropriate placement.
Furthermore, I ask that
the whole issue of wind-generated power be more closely examined and other
alternative and consistent forms of energy production be researched. Australia
has time to do the research because, in the short to medium term, nothing
we do to lower green house gas emissions makes a blind bit of difference
in terms of the global picture. Not while countries like the USA, Japan,
China, India etc. continue to consume energy at a rate which makes ours
look like a spit in the ocean. Australia can get it right and make a difference
in the long term by leading the world in the right kind of renewable energy
production.
But for now I ask you to
look at the very real and worrying plight of some ordinary, decent folk
in beautiful South Gippsland. Please.
Sincerely yours,
Tom Reakes.
|